Back to main page

The Topic: More Geektitude

Yellowbeard2
Ok, so, I was watching Enterprise last night and there was a running fight in hyperspace between the NX-01 (is that right?) and a bunch of little spherical SUliban ships. The Suliban ships were manouvering around and at one point the enterprise alters course by 10 degrees, but the Suliban all manage to stay right with her (I am assuming, being a ship, that the Enterprise is a her). Now, here's my problem: at speeds many times faster than light, and assuming that geometry works the same even at those velocities, then a 10 degree angle of change in flight path would, in short order - even in the subseconds it would take the suliban's ships' computers to make a course correction - mean that the Enterprise would be suddenly very far away - as, at that speed, according to some rudimentary trig work, even a 10 degree angle change would make sin opposite divided by hypotoneuse equal to approximately a fuckload.

So how do they keep up?

Responses:
Crow T. Robot
Wait, aren't the Suliban from the future or something? Maybe they knew that the Enterprise was going to do a course correction!
Tom Servo
Well, here's the thing, Yellowhead, in outer space movies and TV, you ever notice how they say a ship is so many thousands of miles/kilometers/clicks away, yet they both appear on the screen as the same size? Actually showing ship to ship combat at those scales and speeds would be incredibly boring; so yeah, the ships are very far apart, but they show them being much closer so they can spend their effects budgets on more than just plotting a distant point in the sky.
Crow T. Robot
No, I'm pretty sure it's because they're from the future!

Average rating: 4.55